Illustration comparing a sliding glass door with a built-in pet door pane and one with a pet door insert panel, with the text Replacement pane or insert?

Sliding Glass Pet Doors: Replacement Pane vs. Insert Panel

Quick answer: A replacement glass pane with a built-in pet door is custom-made for your door, so it fits and looks like part of the slider. An insert panel is a separate panel that sits in the door track. Inserts are renter-friendly and easy to remove, but because they're made to fit many different doors, they often don't seal well and can keep your slider from locking the way it did before. They also take up part of your doorway.

JGM pet door with a beige frame built into a sliding glass door pane, on a brick patio next to a stucco wall

A JGM pet door built into a custom replacement pane

At a glance

Replacement pane Insert panel
How it works A new glass pane with a pet door built in replaces the glass in your sliding panel A separate panel with a pet door sits in the track next to your sliding door
Fit Custom-made to your door Made to fit a range of doors
Weather seal Fits in your existing frame Often doesn't seal properly
Door lock Your sliding door's frame and lock aren't changed The lock may not work the same with the panel in place
Doorway Your slider still opens to its full width Takes up about 2 to 3 feet of the opening
Renter-friendly? Yes. Changes the glass in your door. You keep the old pane Yes. It can be removed when you move
From JGM Measured, ordered and installed by our team We don't sell inserts, but we can install one you've bought

Option 1: A replacement pane with a built-in pet door

This is how JGM makes sliding glass pet doors. We never cut glass on site. Instead:

1

We measure your sliding pane

We measure the glass in the panel that slides, not the fixed panel.

2

We order a custom pane

A new replacement pane is made with a cutout sized for the pet door you choose.

3

We install it in your existing frame

The new pane goes into your sliding door's existing frame, with the pet door built in.

Pros
✓ Custom-made to fit your door
✓ No cutting into walls or doors
✓ A clean, built-in look
✓ Dual flaps in a pet door sized for your pet
Things to know
✕ Custom work, so it isn't sold online
✕ Professionally measured and installed in Phoenix, Tucson and surrounding Arizona cities
✕ Renting? Check with your landlord first, since it replaces the glass in the door

Option 2: A pet door insert panel

An insert is a tall panel with a pet door in it. It sits in the door track beside your sliding panel, and the slider closes against it. Because inserts are made to fit a wide range of sliding doors, they aren't built for your specific door.

Pros
✓ Renter-friendly: no permanent changes, and it comes out when you move
✓ Nothing to cut
Why we don't recommend them
✕ Inserts often don't seal properly against your door and track
✕ Your sliding door's lock may not work the same with the insert in place
✕ It takes up about 2 to 3 feet of your doorway, so you have to squeeze through when the slider is open
✕ JGM doesn't recommend inserts and doesn't sell them
Already bought an insert? Our team can install it for you in our Arizona service area. Because inserts aren't made for your specific door, we can't guarantee a perfect fit, a proper weather seal, or that your door's lock will work properly once it's in. Call (602) 738-3667 for details.

Which is right for you?

Choose a replacement pane if…
You own your home and want a pet door that fits your slider exactly and looks built-in.
Consider an insert if…
You're renting or need something you can take out, and you're OK with a narrower doorway, a looser seal and possible lock issues.

Not set on sliding glass? Compare all three options in our guide to wall vs. door vs. sliding glass dog doors. A wall mount next to your slider is another way to keep your glass door as it is.

Frequently asked questions

Do you cut my existing glass?

No. We never cut glass on site. We measure your sliding pane and order a new replacement pane with the pet door cutout already made.

Will an insert make my doorway narrower?

Yes. An insert sits in the opening beside your sliding panel, so it usually takes up about 2 to 3 feet. When the slider is open, you'll have to squeeze through a narrower gap. A replacement pane keeps the full opening.

Do you sell pet door insert panels?

No. We don't sell inserts and generally don't recommend them, because they're made to fit many doors and often don't seal or lock properly.

Can you install an insert I already bought?

Yes, in our Arizona service area. Since inserts aren't made for your specific door, we can't guarantee a perfect fit, a proper weather seal, or that your lock will work properly.

Is a sliding glass pet door renter-friendly?

An insert is, because it can be removed. A replacement pane changes the glass in your door, so check with your landlord first.

I'm outside Arizona. Can you help?

Contact us at (602) 738-3667 and we'll help you find the right option.

Get a free sliding glass quote

We measure, order and install your custom pane in Phoenix, Tucson and surrounding Arizona cities.

Sliding Glass Pet Doors Call (602) 738-3667

Monday through Saturday, 8am to 5pm Arizona time.

Back to blog